Friday, 21 March 2014

My FNMI Experience - An Essay.

My name is Chris Scholten. I am a student at Red Deer College studying secondary education. The question of how I came to be “here” could lead me anywhere, depending on how far back I wish to go. I ended up at Red Deer College as a result of grueling application and student loan processes, which has been still relatively easy thanks to ever-improving technology in schools that I had access to. I did not have to stray too far yet, and already I feel myself being pulled into a whirlwind of contemplation – how did students get into post-secondary school without having the privilege of applying over the internet? The answer, I suppose, is quite similar to the way underprivileged young adults are restricted to entering today: traveling all around the city looking for places where they can acquire the proper paper work. Fill it out. Travel to various other places to submit them. Realize a number of forms containing mandatory legal, personal and other  information are missing. Go back to all those places again. Fill out the forms again. Repeat until either you finally get in, or give up and see if a job has opened up at Home Hardware. I could go on about how it’s even harder for aboriginal people to apply to college despite the province’s best efforts, but I’ll leave that topic for another time.
            As far as my actual life journey, well it’s a pretty simple story, as it centers mainly in the Red Deer area. Most of my life was spent here, though much of it was spent moving around between various small towns that I don’t remember very well. My mom and dad had an on-and-off relationship until I was 8; they had me when they were 17, got married when I was 6, and were legally separated by the time I was 8. Whether they were together or not, my brothers, sister and I lived with our mother until I was 10. It was during that time that we did most of our moving. Our mom never had a stable financial situation, and even though my dad helped out whenever he could, they were both very young, and their career options were limited. One weekend when I was 10, we were on a court-ordered weekend visit with our dad, when my mom showed up for some reason. They got into a huge fight, the cops got involved, and the next thing we knew, we were now living with our father, and all we had with us was what we’d packed for the weekend. Our dad took the sudden shift very well in some aspects – within a week or so, he had bought us some new clothes and got us enrolled in a new school. When I was there, I had volunteered to take care of this one little guy every other recess whose name was Galen. He was part Native, though he never really knew his background. We always had fun playing together, and our favorite thing to do was rough-house during recess for the rest of the school year. When I was in grade 6, my dad brought a woman to move in with us. She had two kids and another on the way, thanks to my dad. As for her two kids, their names were Helaenna and… Galen. Well, hello again.
Of course, as I mentioned before, I never found out about Galen and Helaenna’s Native heritage. Either his family didn’t know or they didn’t care. It just wasn’t something anyone talked about. My father and my new stepmother raised the seven of us kids to be Christian, and so everyday we would read the Bible after supper, and every Sunday we would dress up to go to church. Galen didn’t like this at all, not because it violated any traditions or values of his, but because he wasn’t used to living in such a strict, conservative household. In his old life, he ran and played carelessly; he was quite a hyper and rambunctious child. But my dad had his own way of doing things, and while the rest of us stayed quiet if my dad threw a fit over things not being done exactly the way he wanted it, Galen was often the first to lash back, and this caused a lot of havoc between not only him and my dad, but between my dad’s family and his mom’s family. Of course there is a lot more to the story than this, but I know his part best. The notable thing is that the rest of us (other than the youngest) had plenty of time to be scared into behaving like good little boys and girls, but he never really settled down. My stepmom left with her kids and the youngest when I was 18, and Galen is still a smart-mouthed little rebel to this day.
My family sort of fell away from the church scene when I was about 14; I continued going to church and prayed to God and read the Bible quite devoutly until I was 19. During this time, I made friends with a Native named Stan. I met him in church, and I was charmed by his honesty and his mission to overcome the adversity he faced due to his heritage. This was the closest I had ever come to seeing the true nature of an Aboriginal person at that time. Every other time I had ever encountered a full-blooded Native Canadian up close and personal, he or she was poor, disheveled, almost always drunk, and either panhandling or offering to do some odd job for a couple dollars. It was no mystery to me why my dad was always going off with his “drunken Indian” jokes, even though I made no secret of my disapproval every time I heard them. I knew there were “good Indians” out there, but as far as I was aware, they all resided at those tourist sites where elementary schools take kids on field trips to learn about “early” Native American cultures. So to see a Native person who was “just like us,” one who I could take home to my family and say, “See, Dad! They’re just like us; now will you stop with the racist jokes, already?” He started going to my high school and our friendship grew from there. Eventually, due to growing tension in my home, I was ready to move out on my own, and I could see no better possible roommate than Stan. I was warned about Stan; people were telling me moving in with him might not be a great idea, but I brushed them off, dismissing them as clinging to prejudices which would soon be removed once I came out of our 12-month lease and told them all what a wonderful experience it was. How disappointed I was when I realized that he too was, to a degree, an embodiment of the stereotypical “drunken Indian” – a young man addicted to alcohol, cigarettes and marijuana, who liked rap, petty theft, breaking and entering, and hated going to work to pay his share of the rent. How hopeless I felt when I realized this just days after we had signed the forms and moved all our stuff in.
I felt bad, though, because I knew it wasn’t that simple. He had his own demons, and his personal struggles, like mine, developed throughout our childhood. I tried to be as encouraging as I could, and offer my help whenever he asked, without (intentionally) prying. But nevertheless, the tension was there. He was the brown man, and I was the white man. From a historical point of view, I represent the same people who took his people’s land and rights away and made life so difficult for his people in the first place. Even though my ancestors are mainly Dutch, and, to my knowledge, didn’t immigrate to Canada until the 1960’s, I, being a Caucasian, represent the people who introduced his ancestors to the life of the wealthy white man, tore away their identity to make it possible for them to adapt to our culture, while at the same time making it nearly impossible to live their lives beyond the limits our people set for them. The way I understand it, the First People were told they should become like us, but they weren’t allowed to be too high in the ranks, lest they gain too much power and seize back control. As far as the whites were concerned, once we no longer needed them, they didn’t exist. And that is sort of how I see them being treated today.
But I needed Stan. He was more than a roommate. He was my friend. For me, friends have always been a scarce commodity, and so I tried to treat every one as sacred. I still don’t know to this day if he felt I was trying too hard to make him “adapt”; then again I was trying to adapt myself. I wanted more for Stan than what he was used to. But so did everyone else. One time he showed me a giant photo album full of pictures from all the camps he’d been put into – he was once an avid Boy Scout or Cadet or something. Since his infancy, I could see that people were trying to make him adapt to a white man’s society, keep him from growing up and being a “delinquent,” because he was considered “at risk” due to his “rough” family history. I was there almost every time he went on a job hunt, for moral and emotional support. He didn’t have much luck being accepted, for various reasons which may or may not have included his ethnicity (just as it may or may not have been due to his love for poorly-timed sarcastic remarks). As for the smoking and the drinking, I was a smoker, a toker, and a drinker myself, so I certainly was not going to be the one to call up TLC and host an intervention for him. All I asked is that he not over-consume, considering his tendency to become belligerent when drunk, and to consume at appropriate times, i.e. not when we’re still trying to move our stuff into the house using my dad’s truck. Nevertheless, he wasn’t a monster. He was generous with his money when he had money to give. He offered temporary shelter to those without homes. He often was the one who went grocery shopping and was good at keeping the house clean.
It pains me to see that all these simple character flaws are so easily attributed to race, but at the same time, it begs the question: how likely would he have been to grow up with the exact same experiences had he been of a different ethnicity? I feel like the fact that he is a native guy who dresses a certain way in public helps reinforce Native Canadian stereotypes in the minds of passers-by. Many people believe Natives in general to be poor, cheap drunks who get loud, rambunctious and violent, and should generally be avoided if seen in public or on the street. These assumptions have ambiguous origins, but they are very different from reality, even more so that I originally knew. For example, in the U.S., 78.9% of the 68,000+ Native Americans and Alaska Natives 25 or older who had received a bachelor’s degree had received theirs in a field of science and engineering in 2011 (United States Census Bureau, 2012). As for alcohol and drug use, it’s not nearly as prevalent as some of us think. According to an American survey on drug and alcohol use from 2007, studies have shown that there are, by percentage, more Caucasians who consume alcohol than Native Americans (they also drink more than Hispanic Americans, Asian Americans and African Americans) (Chartier, n.d.).
Yet, what the numbers say and what the public sees are still very different, and this has a profound impact on Aboriginal people’s ability to enter post-secondary school and well-paying, satisfying careers. In a research project done in Toronto consisting of 24 aboriginal youth aged 15-25, less than two thirds had completed high school; three were currently attending college and none were attending university (Baskina, 2007, p. 5) What is society doing to help the situation? I don’t pretend for a minute to know what exactly is going on around here with the government and all their specialized Aboriginal programs and events and what-not. However, I do see that a need for improvement has been acknowledged, and initiatives have been taken here in Alberta to do so. In February 2002, Alberta Education devised the FNMI Education Policy Framework. Its long-term objective included improving academic success for FNMI students from Early Childhood to Grade 12 and through post-secondary education, as well as “Foster[ing] a greater appreciation and understanding by all Albertans of First Nations, Métis and Inuit people.” (Alberta Learning, 2002, p.13) Through this, the public school system in Alberta has been able to recognize that FNMI people want their children to adapt and thrive in Western society, but they also want them to remain aware and connected to their cultural roots (Alberta Education, 2012, p. 10)
I hope this paper has been a satisfying demonstration of my knowledge so far on FNMI education needs. What I have discovered while writing it is just how little I actually know in comparison to the presumptions I had before. The above two documents from Alberta Education would be a great resources to read over while continuing my journey toward becoming a teacher. I will also make it a goal to check for more progress reports on the FNMI Education Policy Framework, to keep me up to date on what’s being done to improve the quality of education for Aboriginal students. But overall, I believe the best course of action when I start teaching will be to treat them with as much care and respect as I will with every other student I meet, and acknowledging them all as individuals with unique needs, goals, tastes, talents and approaches to learning.





Works Cited:
Retrieved from
Alberta Education (2002). First Nations, Métis and Inuit Education Policy Framework. (2002). Retrieved from Alberta Learning website: http://www.education.alberta.ca/media/164126/framework.pdf
Alberta Education (2012). Successful Practices in FNMI Education: Collaborative Frameworks Building Relationships Companion Resource. Retrieved from Alberta Government website: http://education.alberta.ca/media/6862538/collaborative%20frameworks%20-%20building%20relationships%20ver.%201.pdf
Baskina, C. (2007). Aboriginal Youth Talk about Structural Determinants as the Causes of their Homelessness. First Peoples Child & Family Review, 3(3), 31-42.
Chartier, K. (n.d.). NIAAA Publications. Retrieved March 22, 2014, from http://pubs.niaaa.nih.gov/publications/arh40/152-160.htm
Ridgeway, S. (2013, June 21). Common Native American Stereotypes Debunked — Everyday Feminism. Retrieved March 22, 2014, from http://everydayfeminism.com/2013/06/common-native-american-stereotypes-debunked/
United States Census Bureau (2012, October 25). Facts for Features: American Indian and Alaska Native Heritage Month: November 2012 - Facts for Features & Special Editions - Newsroom - U.S. Census Bureau. Retrieved March 22, 2014, from http://www.census.gov/newsroom/releases/archives/facts_for_features_special_editions/cb12-ff22.html#SKIP_HDR


Mark: 72%

No comments:

Post a Comment